Where to order Thanksgiving pies — 24 Chicago spots to get your pumpkin, pecan or sweet potato fix
Everyone needs a little slice of heaven this Thanksgiving, and these Chicago pie shops, bakeries and restaurants are ready to serve. Traditionalists will be happy to find plenty of pumpkin, sweet potato, pecan, apple and cherry here. But for those who want to go deeper into pie territory, there are chess, chocolate, cranberry and lots more choices — even a few cakes and other desserts.
No matter the flavor you decide to pick up, order ahead. The Thanksgiving preorder season is a frantic time for bakers; many run out and many cut off orders early. Do not wait until a few days before Thanksgiving — don’t even wait until a week before. (Indeed, one bakery’s pickup deadline is Friday.) Check the bakery or restaurant’s website for pickup times and dates, many require customers to select a pickup time window.
Order a whole creme brulee pie or double chocolate tart ($60) to complete your Thanksgiving meal. 302 N. Green St., Chicago, 773-645-1400, abarestaurants.com
Order a signature housemade pie with Thanksgiving options of Oh My! Caramel ($50) or pumpkin pecan ($55), or go another route with the Tall, Dark and Handsome Chocolate Cake ($55). Multiple locations, beatrixrestaurants.com
Bub City River North
Whole pies ($35.95) are available for preorder by Nov. 25. Choose from pumpkin, peanut butter chocolate or country apple. 435 N. Clark St., 312-610-4200, bub-city.com
Whole honey pies ($60) and bottles of wine are available for preorder before Nov. 25. 74 W. Illinois St., 312-527-5586, emachicago.com
Joe’s is offering a large variety of pies for preorder ($44.95) and pickup before Thanksgiving. Options include old-fashioned apple, sweet potato pecan and the house specialty Key lime. 60 E. Grand Ave., 312-379-5637, joes.net
Your flavor options include pumpkin, apple streusel, Door County cherry and Key lime, or opt for flourless chocolate cake ($24.95 each). If your guests will be craving extra chocolate, there’s also a triple layer chocolate cake ($45). Multiple locations, wildfirerestaurant.com