Chicago's best shrimp cocktail: From steakhouse traditional to Mexican coctel

Chicago Tribune |
Nick Kindelsperger |
May 16, 2019
Original Article: "Chicago's best shrimp cocktail: From steakhouse traditional to Mexican coctel"

Faced with a shrimp cocktail, I am powerless. It doesn’t even have to be a good version. I’ll still drop whatever I’m doing and attack. This is even though sometimes my brain questions the whole concept (do I really want a ketchup-based sauce with some terribly expensive seafood?). But any hesitation is but a split second pause before I have a shrimp in hand ready to dunk.

Shrimp cocktail is, to my mind at least, the quintessential appetizer — not the best or most creative — but the one that pops to mind first whenever appetizers are mentioned. This is probably because the shrimp cocktail can be found all over the place, from seafood shacks to fancy steakhouses. It’s so common that when I decided to research the dish, I knew I’d end up in neighborhoods all over Chicago.

That said, when most of us think about shrimp cocktail, the version you get at steakhouses comes to mind first. Honestly, it feels like you could almost revoke a steakhouse’s license if it doesn’t have a shrimp cocktail on the menu. You’ll find the dish at Gibson’s (1028 N. Rush St.), Chicago Chop House (60 W. Ontario St.), Maple & Ash (8 W. Maple St.) and Gene & Georgetti’s (500 N. Franklin St.), and you’ll pay mightily for each order ($22.50, $23, $25 and $22, respectively).

Seafood restaurants

While steakhouse shrimp cocktails are all about making an impression (bigger is always better there), high-end seafood restaurants offer a far more measured approach. They are also, in my research, better. (These places have mostly dispensed with the traditional presentation, favoring laying the shrimp on a bed of crushed ice, with the cocktail sauce in a small saucer.)

When I asked Bill Nevruz, executive partner at Shaw’s Crab House (21 E. Hubbard St.) why the shrimp cocktail served at the Oyster Bar was so good ($5.25 per piece), he said that the success of the dish is 90 percent about the quality of the shrimp.

“We source Mexican brown shrimp from the Pacific side of the Mexican coast,” says Nevruz. “A whole bunch of shrimp can be used for shrimp cocktail, but we think these are the absolute best.”

Nevruz notes that most shrimp are chemically treated, but that Shaw’s gets it shrimp from a co-op called Pacific Shrimp, which refuses to use any chemicals. He believes this results in plumper, more delicious shrimp. If I had to pick the best traditional version of the shrimp cocktail right now in Chicago, it’d be here.

But a number of seafood restaurants are starting to push at the edges of the dish. At Giuseppe Tentori’s GT Fish & Oyster (531 N. Wells St.) in River North, the absurdly juicy shrimp ($8 each) arrive lightly tossed with herbs, which I realize doesn’t sound like a huge deal, except that no other place downtown tosses their shrimp with anything. Portsmith (660 N. State St.) takes it a step further with its version ($16), charring the shrimp slightly before chilling it, which gives each bite an intoxicating smoky aroma.

Media Contact

Emily Clark pr@leye.com 773-878-7340

You May Also Like...

In The Restaurants
Your Summer Ice Cream Checklist
Aug 23, 2019

I SCREAM, YOU SCREAM...we all know the drill so let's get to the good stuff. We've put together a…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Labor Day 2019: Chicago
Aug 22, 2019

Spend Labor Day, Monday, September 2 at one of our Chicago restaurants. From DIY Bloody Mary Bars…

read more >
Openings
Crab Cellar Serves Unlimited Crab & Burgers 5 Nights a Week
Aug 19, 2019

Crab and burgers are just a few of our favorite things so why not open an entire restaurant…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Where to Eat Lunch – Chicagoland
Aug 19, 2019

For that one hour escape from your office, you want to make sure to make most of your lunch hour.…

read more >
How To
This Summer, Grill Like A Chef. Here’s How
Aug 19, 2019

Executive Chef Justin Diglia of Joe’s Seafood, Prime Steak & Stone Crab in Chicago and his…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Gluten-Free Friendly Restaurants in Chicago
Aug 19, 2019

At Lettuce Entertain You, we aim to make finding gluten-free friendly restaurants a lot easier. Many…

read more >
In The Restaurants
11 Ways to Enjoy Fried Chicken
Aug 19, 2019

Fried chicken never fails to satiate our cravings for something meaty, crispy, and delicious. A…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Cheers for Mocktails
Aug 18, 2019

Mocktails are the perfect way to enjoy Happy Hour without alcohol. Whether you don't like booze or…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Kid-Friendly Restaurants: Chicago
Aug 18, 2019

You've been to the zoo, the beach, the pool... the kids are starting to go stir crazy. Here is your…

read more >
Openings
Introducing Quality Crab & Oyster Bah
Aug 16, 2019

Something’s been boiling over at Oyster Bah and we can’t keep a lid on it any longer! We have…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Here’s Where to Happy Hour in Chicago
Aug 15, 2019

TGI- (insert day of the week here)! Here are all the happy hour deals available at Lettuce Entertain…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Where to Brunch this Weekend: Chicago
Aug 7, 2019

If you're anything like us, you plan your weekend around brunch. Here is your guide to all of our…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Here’s Where to Eat the Best Mac and Cheese
Aug 3, 2019

In celebration of everyone's favorite cheesy dish we’ve rounded up some of our favorite…

read more >
In The Restaurants
A Gift Guide for the Food Lover in Your Life
Aug 1, 2019

Whether a birthday, graduation or any other of the countless holidays, we're here to make selecting…

read more >
How To
Recipe: Quality Crab & Oyster Bah’s Shellfish Linguine
Jul 31, 2019

When making pasta at home, it doesn't always have to be heavy and saucy! Quality Crab & Oyster…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Your Perfect Fried Chicken Sandwich is Served
Jul 30, 2019

You can roast ‘em, you can bake ‘em, and you can grill ‘em, but nothing tantalizes the taste…

read more >
In The Restaurants
21 Gluten-Free Friendly Dishes
Jul 16, 2019

We've rounded up our favorite gluten-free dishes from some of our restaurants' dedicated menus!…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Get a Slice of Our Favorite Pies!
Jul 15, 2019

We love sweet and savory pies of all kinds, so open up your pie hole and explore all of the slices…

read more >
How To
Already Fell Off the Healthy New Year’s Resolution Wagon? Let’s Eat.
Jan 13, 2019

"New Year, Same Me" more your speed? Well, we're right there with you. Celebrate one of our favorite…

read more >
In The Restaurants
#LettuceLookBack: 18 of our Favorite Moments of 2018
Dec 31, 2018

It’s been 47 years since we opened the doors of our first restaurant, but 2018 was a year of…

read more >
How To
A Few Of Our Favorite Game Day Recipes
Dec 31, 2018

When you are in the mood to get your hands dirty in the kitchen for hosting your crew or solo…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Fall Harvest’s Best Dishes
Nov 1, 2018

The bounty of fall harvest comes at a time in the year when we are craving the comfort of cool…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Rich Says You’ve Gotta Try: Quality Crab & Oyster Bah
Mar 9, 2018

Welcome back to “You’ve Gotta Try,” a series that chronicles some of our favorite eats around…

read more >
In The Restaurants
This One’s For Our Indecisive Diners
Feb 26, 2018

For all of you indecisive order-ers out there - the "I want to order one of everything on the menu"…

read more >
How To
How To: Win a Valentine’s Day Staycation in Chicago
Jan 28, 2018

Procrastinating on making your Valentine's Day plans? Well, here's an idea, Chicago: A staycation…

read more >
How To
Not Your Average Party Ideas
Dec 18, 2017

The Lettuce Parties team knows the ins-and-outs of all of our restaurants and they've let us in…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Cozy Sips to Kick the Chilly Days
Dec 15, 2017

Braving the winter just got a little bit easier this year with an array of hot cocktails and…

read more >
In The Restaurants
What’s Hot in Hot Sauce
Nov 1, 2017

Welcome to Quality Crab & Oyster Bah, our East Coast oyster Mecca dedicated to serving up the…

read more >
How To
Recipe: Quality Crab & Oyster Bah’s Loddy Toddy Cocktail
Nov 7, 2016

The weather has officially turned, and it's time to cozy up to the fireplace with a good book and…

read more >
How To
Summer Sips: Smash Cocktails
Jun 16, 2016

Say hello to the season of patio drinkin' and cocktail shakin' - summer is officially here. To…

read more >
In The Restaurants
A Few of Our Favorite Brunch Dishes
May 15, 2016

Brunch: An epic weekend meal situated between breakfast and lunch at which it is totally acceptable…

read more >
Openings
Coming Soon: Quality Crab & Oyster Bah
Dec 16, 2015

It’s always exciting to introduce a new member of our ever-growing Lettuce Entertain You family…

read more >
How To
Treat Yourself! Here’s 7 Ways to Use Your Holiday Bonus
Apr 10, 2010

Wondering what to do with your $25 Holiday Bonus from the Holiday Gift Card Promotion? Now through…

read more >

Recent Posts

In The Restaurants
Rosh Hashanah 2019: Chicago
Aug 23, 2019

Rosh Hashanah is Sunday, September 29 - Tuesday, October 1 and our restaurants in Chicago are here…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Rosh Hashanah 2019: Metro D.C. Area
Aug 23, 2019

Celebrate Rosh Hashanah Sunday, September 29 - Tuesday, October 1 at our Metro D.C. Area restaurants…

read more >
How To
New Spots to Play Summer Scratch Off in Chicago
Aug 23, 2019

Summer Scratch Off is here and we're giving our Frequent Diner Club Members 88 days to eat, 88 days…

read more >
In The Restaurants
The Best Time of the Year: Patio Season in Chicagoland
Aug 23, 2019

Warm weather is here, which means al fresco dining is too! We've rounded up the best patios at…

read more >
Openings
Now Open! Whole30 Delivered: Available Exclusively On Grubhub
Aug 23, 2019

Your Netflix and chill just got a whole lot healthier, Chicago! Introducing Whole30 Delivered, a…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Your Summer Ice Cream Checklist
Aug 23, 2019

I SCREAM, YOU SCREAM...we all know the drill so let's get to the good stuff. We've put together a…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Where to Eat and Drink on the Patio in Las Vegas
Aug 23, 2019

Relax in Las Vegas and people watch on the Strip while al fresco dining! Check out our restaurant…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Dine Al Fresco This Patio Season in the Twin Cities
Aug 23, 2019

In the Twin Cities, you've waited all winter and now it's finally time to take it easy and dine al…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Where to Enjoy Patio Season in Metro D.C. Area
Aug 23, 2019

It's that exciting time of year where you can finally eat outside! Enjoy dining al fresco at one of…

read more >
In The Restaurants
For the Love of Lobster: Shaw’s Lobster Festival 2019
Aug 23, 2019

It’s time to paint the town red with Shaw’s Crab House’s Annual Lobster Festival happening all…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Labor Day 2019: Metro D.C. Area
Aug 22, 2019

Spend Labor Day, Monday, September 2 at one of our Metro D.C. Area restaurants that are open and…

read more >
In The Restaurants
Labor Day 2019: Las Vegas
Aug 22, 2019

Spend Labor Day, Monday, September 2 at one of our Las Vegas restaurants that are open and offering…

read more >
Lettuce Consulting Group

Grow Your Business

Learn More
Career Opportunities

Join Our Team

Search Jobs
Latest Articles

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Sign Up Now